Saturday, April 25, 2009

Pointing to overcast sky

Chahta to Bach Sakta Tha
Magar Kaise Bach Sakta Tha?
Jo Bachega
Kaise Rachega?
Isiliye
Main Dhundhuaya
Chitkane Laga
Karah Sakta Tha
Magar Kailse Karah Sakta Tha?
Jo Karahega
Kaise Nibahega?
(Shrikant Verma)
If I dare translate the above lines in English, the translation could be roughly like this –
I could escape if so wished
But how could I?
Who escapes, can’t create
So,
I smoldered
Crackled
Could moan
But how could I moan
Who moans can’t manage
This poetry is from ‘Magadh’. Melancholy dominates Srikant Verma’s ‘Magadh’, his last of four anthologies. He penned most of poems in ‘Magadh’ following disillusionment with politics. He was an AICC general secretary during Rajiv Gandhi’s time but was gradually marginalized. Or, perhaps withdrew himself. He died a thoroughly disillusioned man in 1988.
I am recalling this poetry to reply to some of the comments on my previous blogs.
Some well-meaning commentators have advised me against writing “ too personal things” or “settling personal scores”. They cited rules of blogging to caution me.
I thank them all from the core of my heart, not the least because they thought it fit to comment on my blogs.
But, dear friends, what is the good of blogging if you don’t express your innermost feelings? Admittedly, I am novice in blogging. But I am thrilled by its potential. It has given me the kind of freedom of expression I always yearn for. The blog has turned me what writer Arundhati Roy says, a “one-man mobile republic”.
Me and my senior friend for 25 years Rajesh Pandey often used to lament we don’t have an effective device to reach out to people.
Launching a paper or magazine by individuals like Rajesh or me in this age is simply out of question. Even the ‘high class’ papers are gasping for want of capital. The age of ‘small magazines” is passé.
To me, the blog has come as a divine intervention to raise your voice and be heard across the globe. I recently read the Thomas Friedman’s book “ The World is flat” and came to realise invaluable potential of the blog.
Since then, the idea of starting blogging agitated my mind. And now I am into it.
Dear friends, let me recall another poet Dushyant Kumar’s line
Mat Kaho Aakash Mein Kohra Ghana Hai
Yah Kisi Ki Vyaktigat Aalochana Hai
(Don’t say the sky is thickly overcast
This is someone’s personal criticism)
Should I desist from pointing to the overcast sky for the fear that this might ruffle some individuals’ feathers?
I would welcome criticism and assure you none of the comments on my posts would be deleted unless their language is completely obscene.
Let the thousands flowers bloom. This is the beauty of democracy. This is beauty of secular republic we have inherited.
Blogging is a cultural tool for personal protest and must be used to its optimum potential.
Let me finish this blog with one example.
About a couple of years ago, the RSS-sponsored mega play ‘ Janata Raja” was staged in Bhopal. The play is about Shivaji’s life. Its sets were spectacular, consumes dazzling but acting mediocre. Nonetheless I was delighted to see the play.
Why? Because it was a cultured way of propagating RSS ideology, a far cry from hooliganism the Bajrang Dal hoodlums often indulge in, in the name of saving ‘ Bhartiya Sanksriti”.
Many of my secular friends sneered at staging of the play. They pointed to the state patronage to the play by the Shivraj Singh Government.
Well, the objection to selective state patronage to the play might be justified but we must welcome such cultural and cultured enterprise to propagate any ideology. It is shorn of violence. If theatre becomes a true language of protest, nothing like that.

6 comments:

  1. You welcomed the RSS way of propagating its ideology. But, what you did in your blog is totally against this example. You were too personal and never seen involved in propagating your ideology in a cultural way. You simply named some persons and leveled allegations against them without any reason. Is it that they are not good persons, not talented or not morally sound only because they worked with you or they are the journalists leading a good life.
    This is your personal blog and every other person (about whom you talked) is a separate entity. If it is your personal space, why didn’t you write about your relations with your brothers or any other family members or even with your wife. These are your personal affairs. Your relations with any journalist cannot be termed personal. Differentiate between personal and professional. You use this space, accessed by entire world, against the persons you don’t like for one reason or the other. Maybe, I can dislike a person if he did not borrow me. I hate him because he is rich, I hate him because people know him, I hate him because he is editor of a big newspaper, I hate him because he don’t know English, I hate him because he is good in networking or in making contacts, I hate him because he is not good looking, I hate him because people love him, I hate him because………go on and on….And, I liked him because he work according to my convenience… go on and on…..Where is ideology?

    ReplyDelete
  2. Sir,

    We are all inspired by your writing. People who don't know about blogging make cheap comments.

    I suggest anonymous to first know about blogging. It is a blogger's discretion to write whatever he feels.

    It is the reader's choice to come to tbe blog or not. My blog is my personal diary on the internet and I will write whatever I can.

    My take on issues and people will be on my blog. If someone doesn't agree, he should write his own blog. As students of journalism, we look forward to you writing on various subjects. Thanks.

    Sanjana

    ReplyDelete
  3. It is really nice to see that people are givng so sharp and stark comments on your posts. Criticism means that you are being read. The more one is criticised, the more he or she is being read.

    Keep on writing. It allows our creative juices to flow regularly and protects us from mental logjams. It takes a life time to let people understand our point of view. Often , a life time also seems to be less.

    But i think that we all need not to fall in the fight of agreeing each other with our opinion. Blogging is just for expressing oneself. People should understand that if anyone is writing anything then he or she is not asking or for anybody's concent. Why people always want conclusions , decisions ? They want to paint every thing in either black or white. This is highly judgemental.

    Being judgemental is bad. its against the very core values of this modern world. We try to accept things as they are and try to digest the grey areas as well. Some events and some posts does not give us any answers, it just broadens our horizens of thought.

    Priyanka

    ReplyDelete
  4. Sanjana,
    You are not able to distinguish between personal, professional and public. Your mail address is your personal thing that could not be accessed by others and protected by password. Blog is not. You want an anarchical situation. If people like you would become journalists then only god can save the media.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Ye anonymous kaun hai bhai jisko itni mirchi lag rahi hai. Naam, address, profession likho na bhai agar himmat hai.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Ab Ravi jaise chhichhore log bhi is blog par aa gaye jo himmat hone ki baat kar rahe hai.......koi dangal ho raha hai kya???.....more anarchy.......Ravi you are the right person to follow this blog.

    ReplyDelete